Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress Review

best crib mattressI love writing reviews and decided it was time to write another review on one of the popular crib mattresses – the Colgate Classica I Foam crib mattress. This specific crib mattress has received a lot of positive reviews online at the time of writing. Let’s have a look at some of the special features it has to offer so that you can consider this as one of your buying options.



Features of the Colgate Classica l Foam Crib Mattress

  • Cloth binding provides strong seams
  • Eyelet vents provide continuous mattress freshness
  • Extra firm high quality foam provides a lightweight feel
  • Many medical experts on babies advise using extra firm foam
  • Wet proof, triple layer cover
  • Orthopedic style
  • Durable, with a 10 year warranty
  • This mattress is Green Guard Certified


When it Comes to Babies, Safety Is Your Number One Concern!


With all the high quality hallmarks of a Colgate product, the Classica l is extra thick and exceedingly durable, as proven by one ecstatic reviewer a little later in this review. Safety is of the utmost importance when it comes to the babies’ sleeping conditions; from the crib itself all the way up to sleeping position, sheets and mattress.


Colgate Is Helping to Combat SIDS


Far too many babies are sleeping in less than desirable conditions, causing undue harm and even worse. This is the number one mattress for fighting SIDS. The Colgate baby mattress offers up the perfect conditions, at least as far as the mattress goes; the rest is up to you.


Is this Product Value for Money?


Budget conscious families can save money in many other areas but shouldn’t need to think twice about purchasing this Colgate baby mattress. A word to the wise however, when it comes to purchasing sheets for this mattress; this should not be an area where money is a factor.


This is where the money should be spent!


High quality sheets will last far longer on this mattress. Customer review after customer review sang the praises of this mattress. The ability for the baby to sleep soundly through the night can even be attributed to this mattress.

Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress

What Is so Special


Reviewers whose babies have restless evenings when staying in a strange place always return home to their Colgate baby mattress and sleep soundly. One reviewer was so happy with this mattress that they have kept it in use for over eight years, and it’s still holding up.

Click here to check the price on Amazon

How Much can a Mattress Withstand?


Crawling, jumping, snot, pooh, spit-up and vomit are enemies of almost every baby mattress ever made. The Classica l stands up to all of those and more.


What if You Have a Really Tiny Baby?


Even the smallest babies will not be able to fit between the mattress and the sides of the crib; this was particularly reissuing for one reviewer who had given birth to a preemie. She never needs to worry about her baby’s safety while in the crib.


What’s In a Name?


Colgate is one of the most popular and recognized makers of mattresses for cribs that are made in America. This extra firm Classica l was checked out by one of the nation’s top magazines for consumer products, and came in at number one. Not only that, but the Classica l has been highly recommended by yet another top publication dealing in baby products for more than 14 years.

Colgate Classica I

The Experts Weigh In


Medical experts in the field of babies and what’s best for them highly recommend extra firm mattresses for baby’s crib. Child after child after child can use one of these mattresses and with the proper care, the Colgate Classica I Foam crib mattress will still be in the best of shape.


What Others Are Saying about This Product


If it ain’t broken…


The ecstatic reviewer previously mentioned bought this mattress for her baby over three years ago. Now as a toddler, the child still prefers to use this mattress. They’re expecting another baby soon and have decided to go with the same Classica l by Colgate. At first, they had considered using the three year old mattress that they already had, but their child refused to give it up. Wear and tear on this mattress has been minimal but the reviewer does recommend that you purchase higher quality sheets due to the wear and tear that they will receive because of the mattress’ extra thickness… which by the way, she did not view as a fault.


Square corners seem to be the key


Another reviewer purchased the Classica l after realizing that her baby’s Sealy crib mattress had round corners, allowing for the space of more than one adult hand to slip down next to the mattress in each corner. The Classica l had square corners which solved the problem nicely. The new mattress left enough room for changing sheets between it and the crib sides but would not allow a whole human hand to fit down in between. It is extremely firm and allows for your baby the safety and apparent comfort to sleep through the entire night, which makes a new mother extremely happy.


You can’t do better than five out of five stars


One of the reviewers purchased it because of the great reviews in a publication entitled Baby Bargains. She loves its lightweight build which allows for easy sheet changing and agrees with the previous reviewer on the subject of always using quality sheets due to the thickness of the mattress. And also as one of the previous reviewers, this family is buying a brand new Colgate Classica I Foam crib mattress for their new baby, because the old one is still being used by their first. As a matter fact, from newborn on their first child has and continues to sleep through the night, soundly. They’re not sure whether or not the mattress had anything to do with that, but they are absolutely sure that it certainly didn’t hurt.


Six and counting


Our last reviewer has slept six babies on their Classica l baby mattress for 14 years. Since accidents wipe right off it is still looking good with no stains or tears and is as firm as it ever was. Firmness seems to be a key component when it comes to the Classica I.

colgate classica i foam crib mattress white

Any complaints?


So far only one reviewer said that it didn’t fit her crib due to the fact that the crib they own is a Baby Mod crib (which has an uncommonly rounded frame all the way around). Whereas this is a legitimate problem, all other reviews sang the praises of this mattress because it fits perfectly and tightly in their baby’s crib.




So what do we have here…? Recommended for over 14 years by a top baby products publication, number one in testing of baby crib mattresses by another publication dealing in baby products, a 4.7 out of 5 star rating at the time of writing and this crib mattress has the reputation of Colgate behind it. There can’t be any doubt that the Colgate Classica l, with its extra firm support, is the perfect crib mattress for your baby’s comfort and safety!


Where Can You Buy the Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress?


You can buy this Colgate Classica I Foam crib mattress from various online retailers. Click here to view on Amazon.

Related posts:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *